Prayers and protests at rmit

 at 9:53 am on Tuesday, July 8, 2008

Earlier this year, the Muslim students of RMIT’s Swanston Street campus were informed that the new Muslim prayer room that had just been completed, replete with verses from the Koran on the walls and other culturally appropriate touches, would not be opened as a spacefor Islamic students, but, instead, would be transformed into a second interfaith centre for the campus.

There are all sorts of problems with having an interfaith, rather than a Muslim, prayer room. In particular, there are religious requirements which are not met by an interfaith space. For further background to the issue and more information about these difficulties, click here.

The situation for Muslim students wanting to practice their religion at RMIT is actually worse than we originally thought. For example, the interfaith centre closes at 5 every day, so the evening prayers cannot be performed there and this will cause even greater problems during the month of Ramadan, where there will be no place for people fasting to break their fast.

Since the beginning of semester, in protest at the prayer rooms being shut down, the RMIT Islamic Society has been holding their Friday afternoon prayers in Bowen Street (the main thoroughfare through the Swanston Street campus).

Despite it currently being holidays, these prayers continue with gusto. Each week, there are still 300-400 people involved in the public protest. Considering that this sort of turnout is happening every single week, this campaign would now be the largest sustained student protest that has happened in Australia in quite some time. The RMIT administration has, though, continued to give farcical reasons to justify not giving the prayer rooms back. Someone from the interfaith centre told me, in effect, "as a non-Muslim, I’ve spent lots of time poking around and prying in the area where Muslims are supposed to pray and I think everything’s fine—I don’t see why they have a problem". She quickly scuttled away when it was pointed out that, as a non-Muslim, she shouldn’t be poking around in others sacred space and that the fact that she did was a good illustration of the problems of an interfaith centre. I’ve also been told that it is ‘illegal’ to have a Muslim prayer room. This person, too, scuttled away whe n it was pointed out that Muslims have to attend lectures in a lecture theatre which is part of a Christian church and has prominently displayed crucifixes. So much for secularism on campus.

Each week, the RMIT Socialist Alternative club has been attending the prayers in order to talk to passers by about this anti-Muslim racism at RMIT. We’ve also been discussing questions raised by the campaign with the Islamic Society and using our knowledge as activists to support the campaign wherever possible.

Unfortunately, there hasn’t been more public support for the campaign. For example, none of the elected Student Union office bearers have come down to support the prayers. However, some staff members from the Student Union have attended and helped hand out leaflets to passers by.

It appears that the actions of the Islamic Society have started to have an effect on the RMIT administration and there is some talk of the administration making concessions to the Islamic Society. But, in order to capitalise on that talk, there is a need, as was said in the last sermon, to "remain steadfast until a solution is found". It’s really inspiring seeing people who have been so vilified because of their religion taking such a public stand for their right to practice that religion. Anyone who wants to support the RMIT Islamic Society’s steadfastness should come down to Bowen Street next Friday at midday and support the campaign to save the prayer rooms.

A final note. I’m sure that some people will argue that this is a question of secularism and that the left shouldn’t support the campaign. I disagree. As an institution, RMIT does not care about my personal atheism when it schedules my computer science lectures in a Christian church in front of a crucifix (one of the largest and busiest lecture theatres is a part of the Melbourne City Church on the corner of Swanston and Little Lonsdale). RMIT does not promote itself as a secular institution when it advertises its religious facilities on its website in order to attract international full fee paying students (there are publications on its website which still advertise the Muslim prayer rooms).

Other religious groups are not having their ability to practice their religion as they so choose compromised. This is the key to this issue. It is an attack on the right of Muslims to practice their religion as they choose; in this case, that choice is to have a separate space which abides by specific rules about hygiene, exclusivity and gender.

As the left, I believe we have a duty to defend the right of people to practice their religion. I think this duty is even more vital in periods when adherents of that religion are coming under racist attack more generally. This is certainly the case with Muslims in Australia.
If we attempt to absolve ourselves from responsibility in standing up to what I believe are racist attacks, then we are merely ceding ground to people like the racists in Camden who campaigned against the Islamic school there.

related posts on lw:

12 Comments »

274029

Comment by Dave Latham

July 8, 2008 @ 10:36 am

At Latrobe Univeristy they have Muslim washrooms and I’m pretty sure a spot for prayer as well.  It’s hardly a radical proposal to get one allocated I would have thought.  I have a strong suspicion this campaign will be won quite soon.

Re secularism.  Secularism is about the separation of religion and the state / institutions etc..  A prayer room is not a religious imposition but a service provided to students.  To attend a Muslim prayer room is voluntary so the issue of compulsion or secularism shouldn’t even enter the equation.

Speaking of religious connections, I thought RMIT owned more real estate than the Catholic Church – it’s hard to believe they can’t find a place for a prayer room amongst its vast property portfolio.  Has anyone approached the NTEU?

 

274201

Comment by liz

July 8, 2008 @ 4:02 pm

hey Jo,

thanks for this report. As an ex RMIT SU staffer, I know the frustration that some staff have expressed about the limited involvement from SU office bearers in defending the rights of Muslim students at RMIT. RMIT SU staff have a long history of supporting the Islamic Students space from attacks from the uni – this is not the first unfortunately, and there have been fights over surveillance and security interventions into the space post 9/11 (ie the checking of ID cards and questioning women whose hijab colour didn’t match the picture!; also teaching staff calling security on brown students carrying mutiple bags!) in the past – and they have expressed the same frustration about so little support for such an active group of students…. What is a student union there for if not to resource motivated and active groups of students in a big fight against the uni?! As one SU staffer put it to me:

“its simple: its us versus them. The uni wants to take something  from the students and they want to fight for it. What more do you need to know?”

As for the NTEU, it would certainly be worth asking the SU staff to take it up to them: membership has traditionally been at 100% amongst SU staff.

Keep up the pressure on the office bearers and thanks for this report! See you Friday.

274630

Comment by liz

July 9, 2008 @ 10:30 am

of course, the other problem will be the classic one within RMIT - that most of the decision makers and petty managers in this case will be NTEU members…. with (hopefully) the exception of the evil Pro Vice Chancellor Students, Joyce Kirk. Though I did once hear an NTEU industrial officer boast that they had at least one Vice Chancellor as a member… I hope he was lying.

277684

Comment by maximum_thrust

July 15, 2008 @ 4:16 pm

They can pray in the interfaith rooms. The bigoted belief that other faiths would contaminate the area for muslims shouldn’t be indulged by rmit.

279343

Comment by bill

July 18, 2008 @ 6:35 pm

re: Vice Chancellors in the NTEU

With Maximum Thrust making comments that are literally identical to those made by RMIT’s VC, I’d suggest the NTEU aren’t the only ones harboring!

279853

Comment by Chav

July 19, 2008 @ 3:13 pm

Liz it is my understanding the RMIT branch of the NTEU is now backing the prayer-protest.

280503

Comment by Liz Thompson

July 20, 2008 @ 5:16 pm

Sweet! I rocked up several hours late Friday – I thought it was evening prayers – stupid me…. 

280528

Comment by Cord

July 20, 2008 @ 6:47 pm

Can we ask one of the leaders of the Muslim students to provide us with their own reasons for rejecting the concept of an inter-faith prayer facility?

281561

Comment by John Greenfield

July 22, 2008 @ 3:28 pm

jo

You would do well to make inquiries into what “religion” and “race” mean. Psssssttttt…a religion is not a “race” ergo anti-Muhammadism – a perfectly rational political position – is not “racist.”

I applaud RMIT’s brave stand. Let’s just hope the splodies don’t start detonating.

281601

Comment by Chav

July 22, 2008 @ 5:35 pm

JG! You’re back! How we’ve missed you. I guess you couldn’t resist the pungent stench of Islamophobia emanating from some of the replies to this post.

As for not being racist…round me up some of the many white anglo Muslims in Australia and then maybe we can talk…

281604

Comment by thanhhuong

July 22, 2008 @ 5:50 pm

“you would do well…”  and “I applaud RMIT’s stand”.

Where have you been John?  Getting a lobotomy? Is all you have these days, cliches? 

 

292234

Comment by Chav

August 7, 2008 @ 10:17 am

For those interested in an update on the Muslim prayer protest at RMIT and a discussion of the political issues involved, Socialist Alternative is hosting the following meeting next Wednesday in Melbourne…

‘Anti-Muslim Racism in Australia today’

Featuring Brother Amr S from the RMIT Islamic Society and Liam Ward from Socialist Alternative

When:Wednesday, August 13th, 6.30pm.

Where:Trades Hall, Cnr Lygon and Victoria sts, Carlton.

 

rss feed for comments on this post
trackback uri

leave a comment

hits for this post: 1865